Я, Робот
Reason
Cutieshookhisheadgravely."Thisamountstoanobsession.Whyshouldyouinsistsoonanabsolutelyfalseviewoflife?Admittedthatnon-robotslackthereasoningfaculty,thereisstilltheproblemof-"
Hisvoicediedintoreflectivesilence,andDonovansaidwithwhisperedintensity,"Ifyouonlyhadaflesh-and-bloodface,Iwouldbreakitin."
Powell’sfingerswereinhismustacheandhiseyeswereslitted."Listen,Cutie,ifthereisnosuchthingasEarth,howdoyouaccountforwhatyouseethroughatelescope?"
"Pardonme!"
TheEarthmansmiled."I’vegotyou,eh?You’vemadequiteafewtelescopicobservationssincebeingputtogether,Cutie.Haveyounoticedthatseveralofthosespecksoflightoutsidebecomediskswhensoviewed?"
"Oh,that!Whycertainly.Itissimplemagnification–forthepurposeofmoreexactaimingofthebeam."
"Whyaren’tthestarsequallymagnifiedthen?"
"Youmeantheotherdots.Well,nobeamsgotothemsonomagnificationisnecessary.Really,Powell,evenyououghttobeabletofigurethesethingsout."
Powellstaredbleaklyupward."Butyouseemorestarsthroughatelescope.Wheredotheycomefrom?JumpingJupiter,wheredotheycomefrom?"
Cutiewasannoyed."Listen,Powell,doyouthinkI’mgoingtowastemytimetryingtopinphysicalinterpretationsuponeveryopticalillusionofourinstruments?Sincewhenistheevidenceofoursensesanymatchfortheclearlightofrigidreason?"